Why treating horses like horses, not ‘like kings’, is significant for equestrian sport’s future

Altering the best way we discuss equine welfare – and treating horses like horses quite than “like kings” – might not solely enhance it, but additionally defend our sport for the longer term.

This was the conclusion of a examine on what was stated after welfare campaigners gained entry to the racecourse earlier than the 2023 Grand Nationwide. The paper, printed in Animals, investigated how what was stated might have an effect on public acceptance of involvement of horses in sport.

Gemma Pearson, an equine vet, behaviour specialist and racing fan, advised H&H the paper “wasn’t a straightforward one to write down”.

The examine centered on the commentary from the racing business; its most important message is that though protestors Animal Rising’s goal was to forestall a horse struggling a deadly harm within the race, in the primary, pro-racing figures targeting the best way horses are handled when not racing.

It cites a radio debate two days after the race, by which Animal Rising and representatives of racing featured. However regardless of the campaigners’ repeating the dangers to horses in racing, and public contributors echoing this, “racing’s representatives have been as soon as once more reluctant to deal with Animal Rising’s most important level”.

Dr Pearson added: “Racing ought to have handled these items. They don’t realise they’re digging a grave for racing with their phrases. They assume they’re promoting the game, however don’t have a adequate understanding of social licence rules.”

She in contrast the problem to some on the whole horse sport – specialists have reiterated earlier than that many of the public sees no distinction between the disciplines – akin to if a horse is eradicated for blood.

“The commentator would possibly attempt to handle it by saying, ‘Horses have such skinny pores and skin… a tiny look of the spur,’ however that’s not proper to say,” she stated. “Then individuals ask, ‘Certainly they’re not allowed to put on sharp spurs?’ They’d be higher to say, ‘Really feel sorry for the rider, however that’s a lesson realized; that’s extreme spur use.’ Transparency is essential.”

Dr Pearson stated the way forward for equestrian sport is dependent upon whether or not the general public trusts the business to safeguard horse welfare.

“In the event that they don’t, they’ll insist it’s regulated, which might in all probability be by individuals who don’t perceive horse sport and welfare,” she stated. “We’ve obtained to say the precise issues, and show it, after which the highlight comes off.”

She cited the distinction between zoos and circuses; the latter has largely misplaced public acceptance, however the former has stored it by shifting focus to conservation and training.

“Instances change and folks assume they will push again and cease the change, however truly they speed up it,” she stated.

One other instance is McDonald’s, which got here below fireplace from campaigners about animal welfare. As a substitute of attempting to quash the protests, the corporate engaged unbiased welfare assessors and invested in coaching, confirmed they’d carried out so, and “as quickly as they did that, nobody was inquisitive about what the protestors stated”.

“We should be prepared to have a look at analysis,” she stated. “There was a bent to say, ‘I’ve been round horses all my life; I do know the whole lot.’ Folks really feel threatened, then are inclined to push away the menace quite than take care of it.”

Dr Pearson added that the general public “understands it’s inconceivable to utterly remove danger in sport” however does wish to know the business cares about and is doing all attainable to minimise it.

“The goal of the paper wasn’t to upset individuals,” she stated. “However as a vet who works on racecourses, I would like racing to proceed. I hope this may assist the business.”

World Horse Welfare CEO Roly Owers advised H&H the paper is a “constructive contribution to discussions on how racing – certainly all of horse sport – can evolve the best way they convey to keep up public acceptance”, and that there are two “particularly pertinent” factors.

“Firstly, when responding to public issues, these should be acknowledged straight, together with what’s being carried out to deal with them,” he stated. “It will assist construct belief. Public nervousness about danger of harm and fatality in racing won’t be assuaged by assurances {that a} racehorse has a top quality of life off the observe.

“Secondly, watch out for the mantra that racehorses are ‘handled like kings’. The general public already expects that they obtain the best degree of care. And we all know that for horses to have high quality of life, they don’t should be handled like kings – they should be handled like horses. This implies making certain their psychological wellbeing, in addition to bodily welfare, together with loads of entry to turnout and forage, and the flexibility to socialize with different horses.

“We hope this paper provokes thought and can assist develop how the media, horse sport and the racing group talk about the advantages and challenges inside this most seen demonstration of the inspirational horse-human relationship.”

H&H has approached the British Horseracing Authority for remark.

You may additionally be inquisitive about:

Horse & Hound journal, out each Thursday, is filled with all the newest information and stories, in addition to interviews, specials, nostalgia, vet and coaching recommendation. Discover how one can get pleasure from the journal delivered to your door each week, plus choices to improve your subscription to entry our on-line service that brings you breaking information and stories in addition to different advantages.

H&H information editor

Eleanor is an skilled journalist who spent over eight years working for native and nationwide newspapers earlier than becoming a member of H&H as information editor in March 2016. Captivated with equine welfare and exposing the reality, Eleanor has reported on all elements of the business, from Brexit to anti-bullying campaigns, and from dressage guidelines to mules. Her sport of alternative is showjumping, by which she competes her personal horses, and she or he additionally enjoys reporting at native leaping reveals by to worldwide championships.